Introduction
Jikishinkage-ryū is a lineage of Shinkage-ryū passed down by students of Ogasawara Genshinsai after his return from China upon the death of Tokugawa Ieyasu in 1616. He called his updated approach to swordsmanship Shin-no-shinkage Heihō and viewed himself as the founder of his art.
Similarly, his student Kamiya Denshinsai studied multiple approaches and was regarded as the founder of the line of succession up until the mid 18th century.
At that time, the art’s history was updated by Naganuma Kunisato (Naganuma Kunisato (長沼国郷), n.d.) to include early figures before Ogasawara, including Okuyama Kyūgasai and Kamiizumi Ise no Kami. Instead of viewing Kamiizumi’s Shinkage-ryū as an art with multiple influences, Naganuma settled on naming Matsumoto Bizen no Kami as the art’s founder. This may have been related to Edo period politics or a desire to align with the Shintō of Kashima Jingu rather than the formative experiences of Aisu Iko in Kyushu.
Major Branches
When Jikishinkage-ryū’s divisions are studied systematically, the taxonomy is consistently three lines (opens in a new tab) (Hall 2013; Nakamura Tamio 1999; Iwasa Masaru 2005; Tominaga Kengo 1996):
- Naganuma-ha (長沼派)
- Fujikawa-ha (藤川派)
- Odani-ha (男谷派)
Each faction descending typically speak in terms of a dōtō or keishō and not a sōke.
The orthodox Naganuma house is sometimes set apart as the trunk, historically. The Odani-ha embraced competitive matches and was involved with the Tokugawa Kōbusho. The main Naganuma-ha lineage ended with the banning of the wearing of swords during Meiji, but a small family branch under the Sakai family continues to this day. The Fujikawa-ha continued through early Meiji and was survived by merging into the Odani-ha to become Yamada Jirōkichi’s Seitō-ha. It is also claimed to have an influence on the Kashima Shin-ryū of Kunii Zen’ya.
Another faction, the Nomi-ha, ceased practice after WWII but produced publications detailing much of its densho. The Seitō-ha itself further fragmented after martial arts practice was resumed after the restrictions imposed during occupation (Wikipedia, n.d.).
The main peer-reviewed treatment, Karukome Yoshitaka’s “A study of the branches of Jikishinkage-ryū,” analyzing the training and inter-school match characteristics of the Naganuma, Fujikawa and Odani groups (Budōgaku Kenkyū 46(1), 2013) (Karukome Yoshitaka 2013), and the same author’s AJKF column, which states flatly that in the late early-modern period the school divided into those three branches (Karukome Yoshitaka 2013; Karukome Yoshitaka 2015; Karukome Yoshitaka 2020).
Early Lineage
The biographical details below are drawn from:
〔于?〕寛政十二庚申春 於江戸見坂 長沼庄兵衛芝生宅ニテ傳授記之置 小川彌七 寿海
Kansei 12, kōshin year [1800], spring. At Edo-Mizaka, at Naganuma Shōbee’s Shiba residence, the transmission was recorded and set down (傳授記之置). — copied by Ogawa Yashichi [?]kai. Jukai (寿海) may be Ogawa’s artistic name appellation.
The four Hōjō end with the line 右四本ノ形ハ春夏秋冬ノ四時ヲ表シ、又天地四方ノ圓満ニ象ル也 (“the four forms above express the four seasons, spring, summer, autumn and winter, and also figure the perfect roundness of heaven, earth and the four directions”). Then comes a Heihō denki (兵法傳記; record of the transmission of heihō) with one entry for each head of the line, and almost every entry carries a marginal note in small script (Ogawa Yashichi (小川彌七) 1800). The readings below were checked against the Waseda images (frames 4–8) in November 2026 and replace an earlier transcription of mine that had a number of errors; 〔?〕 marks a graph that remains uncertain.1
That document names the school, in order, 神陰 (Sugimoto), 新陰 (Kamiizumi), 神影 (Okuyama), 真新陰 (Ogasawara), 新陰直心流 (Kamiya), 直心正統 (Takahashi) and finally the Jikishinkage (直心影) that continues today.
A note in the upper margin explains the word heihō itself:
異國ニテハ呉子孫子七書等ヲ兵法ト云。日本ニテハ多田満仲時代ヨリ軍等ニ出ル時〔并?〕平日大小ヲ帯スルユヘ、是ヲ兵法ト云。鎗ハ太平記時代ヨリ初ルヨシ。
Abroad, the Wuzi, the Sunzi, the Seven Classics and the like are called heihō. In Japan, from the time of Tada Mitsunaka, men wore the long and short swords both when going to war and in daily life; for this reason it is called heihō. The spear is said to begin in the Taiheiki era.
The main text then sets out the kami origin of the art:
凡日城之兵法、稽其原委、曰鹿嶋神流者、傳言、本朝將師任起於神代。而其初、天照太神欲降天孫於豊葦原中國之時、遣經津主神〈又齊主神、香取神是ナリ〉・健雷神〈是也鹿嶋神〉、令平諸不順者矣。而今以神職擬之人職、天孫降臨者、蓋准征〔夷〕。大將軍鹿嶋香取之兩神、准副將軍八百萬神、〔恐?〕神威而平伏之。惡神悉追伐之後、鎮坐於常陸國鹿嶋萬世、尊崇之武神也。代以武事鳴于世者、皆無不宗於是神矣。況乎吾家之兵法者、其先親蒙授。是以曰鹿嶋神流。其後嗣々相承、以異記大略如左。
If we examine the origin and details of heihō in the Land of the Sun, the school called Kashima Shinryū is, by tradition, the office of the generals of our realm, arising in the Age of the Gods. In the beginning, when Amaterasu wished to send the Heavenly Grandson down to the Central Land of Reed Plains, she dispatched Futsunushi (also called Iwainushi, the Katori god) and Takemikazuchi (the Kashima god) to pacify all who would not submit. Now, if we liken the offices of the gods to human offices, the Descent of the Grandson corresponds to a campaign of pacification. The two gods of Kashima and Katori were the commanders-in-chief, with the eight million gods as their lieutenant generals; in awe of their divine might, all submitted. After the evil gods had been driven out, the god was enshrined at Kashima in Hitachi for ten thousand ages and is revered as the god of arms. Of those who in every age have made their name by arms, none has failed to honour this god. How much more our house’s heihō, whose forebears received it from him in person: hence it is called Kashima Shinryū. Since then it has been handed down from heir to heir; from various records, the outline is as follows.
The substance is the standard kami-genealogy claim of Kashima- and Katori-related lineages, familiar to many practitioners today. It is interesting that this was necessary at that time, which may have to do with the politics of the mid Edo period — this is around the time the Kashima lineage story is added to Jikishinkage-ryū practice. The densho then gives an entry for each teacher, beginning with Matsumoto Bizen no Kami, here called Sugimoto:
Sugimoto
第一 鹿嶋神流之元祖杉本備前守紀政元。住于常陸國日暮。奉祈鹿嶋之廣前而契神慮、一夜夢授賜一巻之書〈源九郎義經所奉納之書也云〉。正是爲神傳之故、稱之曰神陰流。
First. The founder of the Kashima Shinryū, Sugimoto Bizen-no-kami Ki no Masamoto, lived at Higurashi (日暮) in Hitachi. He prayed before the sanctuary of Kashima, was in accord with the god’s will, and one night in a dream was given a scroll (said to be a writing that Minamoto no Kurō Yoshitsune had dedicated there). Because this was truly a divine transmission, he called it Shin’in-ryū (神陰流).
The small note on Yoshitsune says only that the dream-scroll was one Yoshitsune had dedicated at the shrine. It nonetheless reaches back to the Heian era, as many koryū have done.2 Note too that in this text the name 神陰 begins with Sugimoto, not with Kamiizumi.
The marginal note reads:
杉本ハ足利時代ノ人ニ、山名宗前〔全〕細川ト七年戦ヒノ時、鹿嶋ノ旗頭ニ、首クヨウ〔供養〕度〔々?〕致シ人ニ、鹿嶋ニ七日通夜シテ戦場ヘ出シ人ナリ。
Sugimoto was a man of the Ashikaga period. During the seven years’ war of Yamana Sōzen and Hosokawa [the Ōnin war] he was standard-bearer for Kashima and performed head offerings [for the enemy dead]. Before going to battle he kept a seven-day vigil at Kashima.
Both 備前 and 政元 are clear in the brush; Karukome’s 政之 comes from another witness. The place name is Higurashi (日暮), in Hitachi.
Matsumoto Bizen no Kami was recognized for his valor outside of Shinkage-ryū makimono. According to the Koyo Gunkan Massho Ketsuyobon, related in Chapter 5 of Takeda-ryū Gungaku Zensho Kankōkai (1935)(Takeda-ryū gungaku zensho (武田流軍学全書) 1935), he fought in combat with the spear 23 times in the battles of Kashima and Katori and claimed the heads of 25 officers and 76 ordinary soldiers.
Matsumoto was thought to be one of the senior students of Izasa Choisai, founder of Katori Shintō-ryū. He (or Tsukahara Bokuden) could well indeed have been Kamiizumi’s Shintō-ryū teacher. Karukome analyses early densho to determine that Naganuma Kunisato prepended him to the lineage.
Kamiizumi
第二 上泉伊勢守藤原秀綱者、杉本門下之正統而兵法之達人也。以鹿流應恐神字、改神陰而稱〔乎?〕新陰。
Second. Kamiizumi Ise-no-kami Fujiwara Hidetsuna was the orthodox heir of Sugimoto’s school and a master of heihō. Because the Kashima school’s name ought to hold the character 神 in awe, he changed 神陰 and called it Shinkage (新陰).
So in this account Kamiizumi’s 新陰 is a reverent softening of Sugimoto’s 神陰, not a new school drawn from Kage-ryū. The marginal note reads:
上泉ハ長野信濃守末家ノヨシ、本国〔上?〕刕蓑輪城主也。此人一度信玄ニ仕候ヘ共、信玄信虎ヲ〔追?〕去シタマフユヘ其事ヲ憤リ、〔暇?〕ヲ申受。其後又ゝ諸国武者修行ニ出シ人ナリ。
Kamiizumi was, it is said, of a cadet house of Nagano Shinano-no-kami, lord of Minowa castle in his home province. He once served Shingen, but resented Shingen’s expulsion of [his father] Nobutora, asked for his release, and afterwards went out again on musha shugyō through the provinces.
The standard published form of Kamiizumi’s name is Nobutsuna (信綱) in later sources, but he used Hidetsuna (秀綱) earlier in his career, and this manuscript’s reading is consistent with the older usage. Kamiizumi (上泉) is a family / village name, taken from Kamiizumi village in Kōzuke Province (上野国, modern Gunma). The Nagano clan (長野氏) were lords of Minowa Castle in Kōzuke, and the Kamiizumi served under them.
Kamiizumi trained in Shintō-ryū and then met Aisu Iko (or his son), from whom he learned Kage-ryū and founded his own Shinkage-ryū. The document ignores the Aisu Kage-ryū completely. Jikishinkage-ryū densho from Kunisato’s 1764 mokuroku kudensho onward place Matsumoto as the founder instead. This is an Edo period revision. Previously, each generation (Okuyama, Ogasawara, Kamiya) viewed themselves as the founder of their own unique approach. This is an example of martial traditions becoming more formalized in terms of lineage attestation during the Edo period.
Okuyama Kyūgasai
第三 奥山孫次郎平公重、後號休賀齋。考一流之家系、其先奥平家之末裔也。継上泉伊勢守兵法之正統、而以住于三州奥山年尚矣。日夜詣至於奥山産神之社、祈願爲兵法之津梁。或夜蒙夢於神託、改神陰號神影。爾後舞劍如影随形、警策門人、以震威風於東海。一箇無對其双者矣。既而奉始 東照神君、至 秀忠公及御連枝、共蒙 台命、以奉授兵法之奥義。
Third. Okuyama Magojirō Taira no Kimishige, later Kyūgasai. Tracing the school’s lineage: his forebears were of the Okudaira house. He inherited Kamiizumi’s orthodox heihō and lived for many years at Okuyama in Mikawa. Day and night he went to the shrine of the Okuyama tutelary god and prayed that heihō might be a ford and bridge [for men]. One night he received an oracle in a dream and changed 神陰 to 神影. Thereafter his sword moved like a shadow following its form; he spurred on his disciples, and his commanding presence resounded through the Tōkai. No one could match him. In time, beginning with the Tōshō Shinkun [Ieyasu], down to Lord Hidetada and the collateral houses, he received their command and taught them the inner meaning of heihō.
Okuyama changes the name of the tradition from 神陰 to 神影. The marginal note reads 奥山ハ赤山氏奥平家ノ末裔ノヨシ。奥平家ニ其末有之 — “Okuyama was, it is said, a descendant of the Akayama clan of the Okudaira house; his descendants are in the Okudaira house.”
Okudaira Nobumasa (奥平信昌, 1555–1615) was Tokugawa Ieyasu’s son-in-law — Ieyasu’s daughter Kamehime married Nobumasa. The Okudaira famously defended Nagashino Castle against Takeda Katsuyori in 1575, the battle that effectively established Ieyasu’s military credibility. After that, the Okudaira were retained as major Tokugawa allies and granted significant fiefs (Kanō, then Utsunomiya, eventually Nakatsu). Mikawa was where the Matsudaira/Tokugawa originated. Saying “Okuyama lived at Okuyama in Sanshū for many years” — as the main text does — and adding the note that he came from an Okudaira cadet line, places him squarely inside the Tokugawa home-province network from before Sekigahara.
The claim that Okuyama taught the first two Tokugawa shōgun, Ieyasu and his son Tokugawa Hidetada (opens in a new tab) (徳川秀忠, 1579–1632), stands in the main text, not in a note. The command (taimei 台命) is that of a shōgun or lord, not an imperial one. It is a strong claim, but given the relationship of the Okudaira to the Tokugawa it becomes more plausible that Okuyama was a swordsmanship or strategy instructor to the Tokugawa. Whether this is factual, or an embellishment from 1800, remains unclear; further research would require consulting the Kansei Chōshū Shokafu (寛政重修諸家譜), the comprehensive 1799–1812 Tokugawa genealogy.
Ogasawara Genshinsai
第四 小笠原金左衛門尉源長治、後號源信齋。兵法熟練而入唐、更得妙術、還奥山一派之正統也。有故、改神影之名曰真新陰。百練精金、色轉鮮。
Fourth. Ogasawara Kinzaemon-no-jō Minamoto no Nagaharu, later named Genshinsai. Having become accomplished in heihō, he crossed to China (Tō) and further obtained marvellous technique; returning, he was the orthodox successor of the Okuyama lineage. For [these] reasons he changed the name from 神影 to Shin-shinkage (真新陰). Like refined gold tested a hundred times, its colour turned the more brilliant.
Here, despite the context setting of purely Shintō sources, Ogasawara is mentioned as receiving subtle teachings in China. The marginal note reads:
小笠原公御同家ニ本国信州、天下ニ知ラル程ノ劔術ノ達人。勿論日本ニテ劔術未足ニ思ヒ入唐マテシタル人ニ、唐ニテ妙術ヲ得テ帰リシ人ニ。其時分唐ニテハ明ノ世ノ末ニ、其節甚妙術ヲ得〔シ?〕ユヘ、中華ニテ弟子多出来ルヨシ。長〔張?〕良ノ末ナド門人ニナリシヨシニ。
Of the same house as Lord Ogasawara, home province Shinshū; a swordsman famous throughout the realm. Not content with his swordsmanship in Japan, he went as far as China, gained marvellous technique there, and came back. At that time China was in the last years of the Ming. Because he had gained such marvellous technique, he is said to have had many disciples in China; descendants of 長〔張?〕良 and others are said to have become his students.
This works to establish that Ogasawara came from one of the most prestigious samurai houses: the Ogasawara of Shinano Province (信州 / 信濃国), the same house that developed the Ogasawara-ryū etiquette that formed the basis for samurai conduct. The densho attests that Ogasawara did go to China and there obtained myōjutsu (妙術; marvellous technique), and the note has him teaching there in the last years of the Ming. If 長良 is a slip for 張良 (Zhang Liang), the note ties in with the tradition of the Rikutō Sanryaku; that is speculative. The note says nothing about Korea, or about his being kept from returning.
Kamiya Denshinsai
第五 神谷文左衛門尉平真光、後號傳心齋。最英靈也。改真新陰曰新陰直心流。傳言、神則心也、新直指、而竟做流稱。
Fifth. Kamiya Bunzaemon-no-jō Taira no Sanemitsu (真光), later Denshinsai, a most outstanding spirit. He changed Shin-shinkage to Shinkage Jikishin-ryū (新陰直心流). It is transmitted that 神 is 心, and 新 is “direct pointing”; in the end he made this the school’s name.
The “direct pointing” terminology is borrowed from the Zen jikishi ninshin (直指人心; pointing directly at the human mind). Beside 心 the scroll glosses 明徳 (“bright virtue”), the foundational term of the Daxue (大学): “the way of great learning lies in illuminating bright virtue” (大學之道,在明明德). The Zen vocabulary of the renaming is glossed with the parallel Confucian one. A boxed note beside the passage compares the mind to a clear mirror (明鏡ナリ).
A long marginal note tells a story:
小笠原弟子。此時分京都ニ宮本武蔵ト申劔術ノ名人アリ。右宮本ハ二刀流遣ヒノヨシ。神谷ト雌〔試〕合イタシ度望ミ有。〔則?〕立合十六度ニ及。宮本ハサバノ尾ト申両刀ニテ中段ニカマエシ処、神谷ハ勝ケレ共、右ゝ咄ヲ小笠原ヘ咄ニハ「未逹人ニモ無之」ヨシ申ケレハ、小笠原甚立腹シテ神谷ヲ呵リ、又ゝ小笠原神谷ト雌合致処、神谷ハ宮本流ニテ二刀中段ニ仕カケ、小笠原上段ニテ左右ヘフリ、面ヘ丈夫ニ打込、一度勝シヨシ。
A disciple of Ogasawara. At that time there was a famous swordsman in Kyōto called Miyamoto Musashi, a two-sword man, who wanted a match with Kamiya. They met sixteen times. Miyamoto held his two swords crossed in chūdan in what he called saba no o (mackerel tail). Kamiya won, but when he told Ogasawara the story and said Miyamoto “is not even a master”, Ogasawara grew very angry and scolded him. Ogasawara then had a match with Kamiya. Kamiya took Miyamoto’s style, attacking with two swords in chūdan; Ogasawara, from jōdan, swung left and right, struck firmly to the head and won the bout.
The story turns on the teacher correcting a student’s pride, and on jōdan answering the two swords.
The Kirigami kikigaki no bensho (切紙聞書之辨書) of 1806, which Karukome quotes in full from a copy in the Suzuka family papers (pp. 54–55) (Karukome Yoshitaka 2013), tells the episode the other way round. There is no match with Musashi. When Ogasawara calls Musashi a true master, Kamiya objects that Musashi only beats down lesser men by strength, a conqueror (覇者) rather than a master; Ogasawara, angered, takes Musashi’s part himself:
源信以テノ外立腹シ、我ハ武蔵ヲ殊ノ外信仰也、吾武蔵ニ成、相手ニスヘシト云、止事ヲ不得、立合フ、源信ハ武蔵ノ名代故、両刀ヲ以テ、トツカツト云構ヘ仕掛ル、伝心ハ上段ニ構ヘ、曲尺マテ仕掛ルニ、互ヒ動モナキ故、伝心霊剣ノ意ニテ、右転左転ト動カシ、下段ニスレハ、源信トツカツニテ、上ヨリ挟ミ押ヘントス、伝心下ヨリハ子飛スレハ、二刀トモハ子飛シ返ス、太刀ニテ打割ル、源信殊外感シ、真ニ摩利支天ノ化神也ト称美シ、流義ノ極意幷ニ朱印墨印マテ相授ケ…
Genshin, angered beyond measure, said: “I hold Musashi in particular reverence. I will become Musashi and take you on.” It could not be helped, and they faced each other. As Musashi’s proxy Genshin attacked with two swords in the stance called トツカツ; Denshin took jōdan and pressed in as far as kyokushaku (曲尺). Neither moved, so Denshin, in the spirit of the reiken, worked right and left (uten saten) and dropped to gedan; Genshin, from トツカツ, tried to clamp him from above; Denshin knocked up from below, sent both swords flying, and split him with the returning cut. Genshin was deeply moved, praised him as truly an incarnation of Marishiten, and conferred on him the school’s inner teachings and its seals in red and black ink…
In the 1800 note the teacher wins and the student’s pride is corrected; in the 1806 text the student wins and receives the school. Karukome observes that a licence earned by defeating one’s teacher is found nowhere else in the line’s transmissions.
Takahashi Jikiōsai
第六 高橋彈正左衛門尉源重治、後號直翁齋。寛永而至元禄、誘引門人務兵法。數流派多端而混支流、故以直心正統爲吾家之流號。
Sixth. Takahashi Danjōzaemon-no-jō Minamoto no Shigeharu, later Jikiōsai (直翁齋). From the Kan’ei [1624–45] through the Genroku [1688–1704] eras he drew in disciples and devoted himself to heihō. Because the schools had multiplied and become mixed with branch lines, he made Jikishin Seitō (直心正統; orthodox Jikishin) the name of our house’s school.
Karukome reads the same name, 直翁斎, in this and other witnesses (Karukome Yoshitaka 2013). The marginal note reads:
高橋ハ山城淀ノ城主十万石ニ永井信濃守家臣ニテ達人ナリ。折節主人申付ラレケルハ、筋金ノ鉄撓〔?〕ヲ出サレ「シナイニテ打候ヘ」ト申サレケレハ、再三辞退仕〔候ヘ共?〕是非不及望マレシユヘ、心意丈夫ニ打〔込?〕候処、〔撓?〕ヘコミ申ヨシ。〔右?〕此人大兵成ルヨシ。
Takahashi was a retainer of Nagai Shinano-no-kami, lord of Yodo castle in Yamashiro (100,000 koku), and a master. Once his lord brought out an iron-ribbed shinai and told him to strike it. He declined again and again, but was pressed, struck with full spirit, and dented it. He is said to have been a big man.
Yamada Heizaemon (Ippūsai)
第七 山田平左衛門尉藤原光德、隱遁而曰一風齋。重治手書直心正統的傳之印狀、以付屬于光德。新傳於直心正統流無極之微意、思前顧後、以改流號曰直心影流而已矣。
Seventh. Yamada Heizaemon-no-jō Fujiwara no Mitsunori, who on retiring called himself Ippūsai. Shigeharu entrusted to Mitsunori the seal-certificate, in his own hand, of the true transmission of Jikishin Seitō. Mitsunori newly transmitted the subtle intent of “no extremes” (mukyoku 無極) in the Jikishin Seitō-ryū and, weighing what came before and what would come after, changed the school’s name to Jikishinkage-ryū. That is all.
This is the founding moment of the school under its now-current name. The scroll glosses 光德 with ノリ, confirming the reading Mitsunori. The marginal note reads 高橋門人ニ長沼父ニ、流義甚深。…二六時中無雙之上手。出精稽古ノ節ハ矢立持、武藝ノコト、其外所ゝノ雌〔試〕合、未能ノ心掛シ人ニ — “a disciple of Takahashi, father of Naganuma, very deep in the school’s teaching, peerless at all hours; when training hard he carried a writing kit for matters of the art, and he sought out matches in many places” (the last clause is uncertain). Ippūsai trained in Edo Yagyū Shinkage-ryū and under Takahashi (Jikiōsai), returning to this practice some time after becoming injured.
Naganuma Kunisato
第八 長沼四郎左衛門尉藤原國郷〈山田ノ第三子ニ而達人ゝ〉。光德第三子也。天性敏劔術、弱冠悟其蘊奥。術過二兄、父奇之、遂傳其秘。弟子殆三千、終身教之不倦。只以真實之業、獨能育其才矣。
Eighth. Naganuma Shirōzaemon-no-jō Fujiwara no Kunisato, third son of Mitsunori. Quick by nature in swordsmanship, he grasped its inner depths while still young. His skill surpassed his two elder brothers; his father marvelled at him and at last passed on its secrets. His disciples numbered nearly three thousand, and he taught them untiringly all his life. By genuine practice alone he uniquely brought out their talent.
The “third son of Mitsunori” agrees independently with the 1843 Bujutsu ryūsoroku (Yamada Ippūsai). Naganuma Kunisato is the author of the mokuroku kudensho (1764; read through its 1768 copy, ke05_01032_0001) that I examine in my analysis of the densho commentary (opens in a new tab). Kunisato updated the curriculum, adding several koto (matters) to the art, and expanded the lineage to name Matsumoto Bizen no Kami as its founder. His predecessors, Takahashi Danjōzaemon and Yamada Heizaemon (Ippūsai), regarded Kamiya Denshinsai as the originator of the art, and in writings by Heizaemon in 1708, no mention of Kashima-shinden is made.
The emphasis on Kashima-shinden was an Edo period innovation for that art and hides some of its earlier character. That change of emphasis has only increased in modern times with influences from state Shintō and militaristic Zen popular in the Meiji and Taishō periods.
Naganuma Norisato
第九 長沼四郎左衛門尉藤原德郷、國郷子。既能継箕裘之業、孳々不怠。年三十有六而卒。人皆悼惜之。
Ninth. Naganuma Shirōzaemon-no-jō Fujiwara no 德郷, son of Kunisato. He carried on the family calling (kikyū 箕裘, lit. “winnow and fur coat”, the trade of the ancestors) and worked tirelessly. He died aged thirty-six, mourned and regretted by all.
The scroll gives no reading for 德郷. Since it glosses the same graph in 光德 as nori, the copyist probably read Norisato, though Tokugō is also possible. The Jikishinkage-ryū Shoke-den (諸家伝) typically gives this generation as Tokushige (徳重) instead.
The list closes with 一流別號次序、各宜一覧而知焉 (“the order of the school’s successive names: each may be known at a glance”), and the scroll goes on to the Ryū no maki (龍之巻).
Analysis
Every head from Sugimoto to Yamada carries a marginal note, and the longest are on Kamiya and Takahashi, not on the generations whose claims most needed support. The notes read less as a defence of contested links than as a copyist’s lore about each man: a battle vigil, a lord’s quarrel, a famous match, a dented iron shinai. The legitimating work is done in the main text instead — the kami origin, Okuyama’s Tokugawa pupils, Ogasawara’s crossing to China — and the main text is Naganuma’s.
There are three distinct nominal traditions layered into one curriculum: classical Chinese strategic vocabulary for the named kata, yin-yang cosmology for the stance theory and Japanese densho convention for the principles. This lines up with the same trilingual-classical sensibility visible in the nittō / 得妙術 framing of the Ogasawara section, the Zen and Confucian glosses on Kamiya’s renaming, and the head-note on the Chinese military classics. The 1800 densho is doing more interpretive work in its choice of category labels than a flat list would suggest.
Edo Period Revision
Note that both load-bearing antiquity claims of the Kashima-shinden framing — the Sengoku founder Matsumoto and the divine Kashima descent — are documentary additions made by Naganuma Kunisato in the mid-eighteenth century, contemporaneous with the doctrinal cluster of later topics (相尺・留三段・切落・吟味, and the 十之形 龍尾–曲尺) being added to the mokuroku kuden-sho (Yoshida Katsunori (吉田克禮) 1768; Yoshida Katsunori (吉田克禮) 1768) and absent from Yamada’s Heihō zakki (Yamada Mitsunori, n.d.).
Before this time, Ogasawara referred to himself as the founder of his art, citing his travels to China. Ogasawara’s 1673 menjō describes him as having found the art himself and cites a crossing abroad (異朝渡). This nittō motif is in the primary densho at the early 17th century Ogasawara stage, not a later gloss made in order to gain reputation by association with late-Ming dynasty. Kamiya similarly regarded himself as founding his own art, having studied fifteen ryūha.
Later masters regarded Kamiya as the art’s successor until Naganuma Kunisato revises the curriculum and rewrites its history, inserting Matsumoto (Sugimoto) Bizen-no-kami Masamoto (松本備前守政元) as ryūso in 1764 and likely invents the notion of divine revelation from Takemikazuchi-no-kami (“Ōga Ikken (大禾一件)” 1773).
I believe this is a witness to a transition of thinking from late Muromachi period practice of swordsmen who saw combat, developing unique experiences and insights, and later Edo-period professional swordsmanship instructors who institutionalized these earlier methods. The shift from the personal to the institutional lies in Takahashi, who called his line Jikishin Seitō-ryū (直心正統流; orthodox transmission) (Takahashi Shigeharu 1686).
While Naganuma reaches back to Matsumoto, Kamiizumi likely learned his Shintō-ryū from Matsumoto or Bokuden (whose dates fit far better than Iizasa Chōisai’s) and maintained both the Aisu Kage-ryū content of Empi and Tengushō in his early teaching, as well as the Shintō-ryū gokui in the form of a set he called nanatachi as an important upper-level set, the empi and tengu-sho of Aisu Ikō, as well as his own Sangakuen and Kuka kata sets, and marobashi gokui teachings (“Jikishinkage-ryū Hisho Ichi (直心影流秘書一),” n.d.; Kawasaki Tōnojō Yoshioi 1789).
Naming Conventions
Historical names have several portions or variants:
- gō (号; art-name / sobriquet)
- imina (諱; true given name / “taboo name”)
- tsūshō (通称; common name / by-name) — the everyday name plus any titular suffix, e.g. Shōbee-no-jō (庄兵衛尉).
The gō is a self-chosen style-name, usually ending in -sai (斎; abstinence/ritual purity), -an (庵) and the like; the master’s “studio name.” In this house, Katsuzensai (活然斎), Shinpansai (真帆斎), Seisai (静斎), Ittokusai (一徳斎).
The imina, the real personal name, used formally and posthumously but avoided in direct address in life (hence “taboo”). This is the element carrying the Naganuma generational character 郷 (sato): Kunisato (国郷), Tsunasato (綱郷), and so on.
The tsūshō is the common name, the everyday name plus any titular suffix, e.g. Shōbee-no-jō (庄兵衛尉).
A full name would read tsūshō + gō + uji + imina. For example, Naganuma Shōbee-no-jō (tsūshō) Katsuzensai (gō) Fujiwara Tsunasato (imina).
Other Influences
The flagship Sakai domain — Shōnai (Tsuruoka), with its han-school the Chidōkan — maintained a line of Jikishinkage-ryū. Onozaki Norio’s Shōnai-han no bujutsu (庄内藩の武術; Shōnai domain martial arts), compiled from the Chidōkan and the Tsuruoka/Sakata archives, lists the domain’s kenjutsu lines as Shinkyū-ryū, Okuyama-ryū, Santomi-ryū, Inazuma-ryū, Shinshin Yagyū-ryū, Tamiya-ryū and Jikishinkage-ryū.
Jikishinkage-ryū was also taught in other domains, besides Numata (Jikishinkage-ryū (直心影流), n.d.; Numata-shi Shi, Shiryō-hen 2: Kinsei (沼田市史 資料編2 近世) 1997). Fujikawa Seisai (1791–1862), after the 1853 arrival of the American ships, was invited by the Tōdō house (藤堂家; Tōdō family house) Tsu-han in Ise and the Yanagisawa to instruct their retainers. The Sakai family from Tsu-han continued a practice of Jikishinkage-ryū kenjutsu.
In the early 20th century, a family practice of Fujikawa-ha Jikishinkage-ryū served as part of the early education of Kunii Zen’ya, who later was regarded as “Shōwa no Imamusashi” (昭和の今武蔵; “the Musashi of the Shōwa era”) and whose Kashima Shin-ryū gained great acclaim.
Isezaki Araki-ryū’s central line, started by the 9th-generation shihan Komine Bundayū and his student Kurihara Ioji (Gomoji) Masashige, developed many of its weapon-on-weapon kata through exchange with the neighboring traditions of the area, most notably Kashima Shinden Jikishinkage-ryū and Kiraku-ryū.
References
The sources cited on this page are collected in the site source register.
End Notes
-
The earlier transcription, made with machine help for an earlier draft, misread several graphs (日暮 as 日春, 直翁 as 直心, 共 as 其), joined glosses into the main text, and supplied marginal notes that are not on the scroll, notably a note on Ogasawara in Korea. Arguments built on those readings have been removed from this page. ↩
-
Some contemporary Katori Shintō-ryū practitioners when interviewed mention Yoshitsune as an influence through Kuramadera, so one wonders if mention of Yoshitsune in this densho is a Shintō-ryū influence on the art. ↩
